Indifferent In America
At first glance, Rittenhouse Square can easily be taken for a slice of serenity in the urban tangle that is center city Philadelphia. A model citizen of the metropolitan world, Rittenhouse is the type of neighborhood you could picture raising a family in: safe, vivacious, & prosperous. Buzzing while not bursting, “the square” gives rise to an eclectic mix of young and old alike. Here, the city's social elite, culturally hip, and corporate stiff all frolic under the same spanned canopies of its towering trees. In between swallows of tofu tarts and apple martinis, locals spend their lunch breaks lounging around one of the square’s many posh eateries, nonchalantly trading gossip as life gently rolls on by. As day turns to night, they simply trade in their button-downs for their bursting-outs and head for the bourgeois lounges and trendy nightspots dotting the area. It’s here where they finally top off their tanks with the finest in over-priced, ego-driving extravagance. Excess, indulgence, affluence….life sure is good in around these parts. That is, as long as those pesky Have-nots stay the fuck out!
My girlfriend happens to be one of the lucky ones who was fortunate enough to find employment with one of the many thriving businesses that call Rittenhouse Square home. A stable gig, decent pay, and a corporate environment that even a staunch anti-nine-to-fiver like myself could tolerate have all done wonders to remedy the forty-plus-minute commute she endures daily. To show my appreciation for her continued endurance, oft times I will make a surprise trek into RHSQ as I did recently on warm & sunny Friday afternoon. I planned for a relaxing evening of dinner & drinks while later getting wooed by the wonders of First Fridays. What I got was a lesson in indifference in America..…
Having time to kill prior to meeting up with my girlfriend, I made my way to the heart of Rittenhouse Square, its park. There, I decided to post up at its entrance and get lost in one of the city’s rag-tag alt-weeklies. Thumbing my way through the swath of political diatribes, cultural happenings, and transvestite escort ads, I couldn’t help but be distracted by the repetitive mantra being asked in the near distance, “Would you like to help save the children?” “Would you like to help save the children?” “Excuse me, sir?? Would you like to help save the children?” “Ma’am, Ma’am, just a second of your time, please!” “DOES ANYONE CARE TO HELP SAVE THE CHILDREN?!?!?!??!?” The solicitation was originating from two young men wearing red-colored polo shirts emblemized with an official seal of charity.
Charities soliciting help is nothing new to Rittenhouse Square. On any given week, non-profit organizations lay claim to the area surrounding the park in hopes that someone…anyone…will find value in their cause. It makes complete sense that groups like Amnesty International and The Salvation Army would choose here to take up their pleas for help. After all, the people of Rittenhouse are among the most affluent of Philadelphia’s population. Tending to be financially sound, socially adept, emboldened (or so they act), and politically oriented, they are, as Marilyn Manson would put it, “The Beautiful People”. But if beauty is in the eye of the beholder, then surely this was the ugliest crowd of people I’ve seen in quite some time. Because, for over an hour, I sat and watched as well-to-do passer-by after well-to-do passer-by deflected the pleas of help by these two young men armed with only a clipboard and their compassion as they tried to save the lives of children unlucky enough to have been born in sub-Saharan Africa and not Rittenhouse Square.
“I’m sorry but I’m running late.……….. Oh, I’m sorry. I’d love to help but I’ve got to get back.……… Oh, I’m sorry but I don’t have time. ………. Oh, I’m sorry but….. oh, I’m sorry…. … oh sorry….. gee I’m sorry but…. sorry…” ……Sorry after sad sorry. The stream of bullshit excuses spewing from these dismissive, over-privileged brats seemed to have had no end.
As I looked on at this regrettable display of indifference, I caught eyes with one of the young men. He could see that I felt sorry for him. In a half-sarcastic, half-disgusted tone, I called out to one of the young man, “Hey, if you’re bored, you can always try your luck on my ears.” And that he did….. His name was something rather easily forgotten but his determination was something that I never could. A champion for helping poor, third-world people, the University of Penn student explained that in the hour or so that he’d been out there, a mere one person stopped to listen to his oration. While he admits that one of his goals was to solicit monetary contributions, he made it quite clear that ultimately, it was the hearts & minds of the people of Rittenhouse that he was after. And that, he said, is something no money in the world can buy… one hour, one person. Sad.
After talking with this young man for quite some time, we exchanged information, shook hands, and proceeded to carry on in our own directions. As I walked on, I thought back to all of the dismissive excuses I heard that day. And ultimately, I would have to agree with the passer-bys……. they are sorry. No, not for one minute do I think they’re filled with regret & anguish knowing they could’ve been the difference between life and death for a starving child, but because they’re a sorry testament to a sad truth about human nature: the more you have, the more you become blind and what starts out of sight, ends out of mind.
We as Americans are taught to feel, think, and act exceptional; like somehow we are different than “everyone else”. Because of this, many of us believe that neglect is an international issue and although no society is void of it, arises here only occasionally and at the fringes of our society. But as the days & months following Hurricane Katrina prove without doubt, class warfare is no longer just a food fight between seventh graders. It is a fact of the new America, and when the people of Rittenhouse Square pass by those two young men, not only are they passing by the have-nots of Haiti, Rwanda, and East Timor, they are passing by the have-nots of Orleans Parish, Flint, and Philadelphia too. Because if you‘ve got nothing, you’ve got nothing anywhere in the world.
Spend more than a moment in a place like Rittenhouse Square and you begin to sense that something is amiss. It’s almost as though you’re helplessly stuck in a surreal episode of Candid Camera or Punk’d. Only in this show, it's tragically real and void of all those preconceived emotions one gets from a man in monkey suit jumping out of the handicap stall in a women’s restroom. But if you happen to be have-not in America looking for bone to bite on, you might as well be a man in a monkey suit. At least that way, you may actually stand a chance of gaining the attention of the fortunate ones who continue to toil in apathy & acquiescence. As for the rest of us, we’ll be busy laboring to meet the status quo, like we always do, while George Bush and the new American Aristocracy post a sign at the entrance to the American Dream reading “Welcome to America. Just don’t bother me.”
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
“Have you not empathy for the weak, then have you only apathy for yourself”
-Anonymous

